Ilta-Sanomat reveals embarrasing error in Reuters feed on Russian North Pole sub expedition
"Images presented by the Reuters news agency last Thursday, purporting to show the Finnish-built MIR-1 and MIR-2
submersibles during a recent Russian scientific expedition to the sea
bed 4.3 kilometres below the Geographic North Pole, have been shown to
be something else again.
The pictures did indeed show MIR-1 and MIR-2 in action, but the submersibles were actually employed at the time in location filming at the scene of the wreck of the RMS Titanic in the North Atlantic, and not under the polar ice-cap.
Those who have seen James Cameron's blockbuster movie Titanic
(1997) will also have recognised the footage, as Cameron used the same
shots in certain sequences of his epic about the 1912 disaster that
were set in modern times.
The images were picked up by numerous media outlets around the world, Helsingin Sanomat among them, and were inserted into news stories as evidence of the successful expedition. Nobody raised any eyebrows.
At least, not until one Finnish reader, a 13-year-old boy from Kemi named Waltteri Seretin, made just this "Cameron connection", and contacted the late-edition tabloid Ilta-Sanomat. The newspaper ran the story prominently in its Thursday edition."
Russia humiliated. Or so it seems:
As the story of the faux pictures broke
and spread to other countries, there were those who jumped to the hasty
conclusion that in fact the entire Russian Academy of Sciences'
expedition was a hoax. It was even thought briefly that the planting of
a titanium Russian flag on the sea-bed - seen as a symbolic claim on
the area, which is rich in natural resources - was the product of
clever image manipulation.
Things are probably not that dramatic: it merely seems that someone at
the normally meticulous news agency arrived at a wrong conclusion of
their own about the images and they were mislabelled or left without
any captions at all.
The incident is doubly embarrassing for Reuters since it follows on
from a case last August in which the news agency published an image by
a freelancer of Israeli bombings in Lebanon that had been dramatised
using photo manipulation, with the addition of smoke rising from
allegedly burning buildings. After that gaffe, Reuters promised to
tighten up its controls on material being put out in its name.
Still this is quite a setback for a Russia that is flexing its muscles and trying to regain former "glory" where loosing face is not acceptable.
Recent Comments